My mother went to high school in the fifties. Poodle skirts! Elvis! Trips to the local malt shop! I make her into Sandra Dee in my head when I think about it. I went to high school in the eighties. Big hair! Stretch pants! Swatches! I could have been a character in a John Hughes film. I'm not sure how to characterize Haley's high school years yet. Skinny designer jeans? What I do know is that the difference between my mother's high school experiences and mine seems much larger than the difference between mine and Haley's. Perhaps we could blame it on the sixties.
When I was Haley's age, I am not sure I ever considered talking to my mom about anything I was dealing with. I didn't even think "maybe I should talk to my mom" and then reject the thought. It simply never came into my head. The thought of her experiencing what I was experiencing—the boy troubles and the friend troubles and the vicious highs and lows—wasn't a concept that made any sense. My mom was simply my mom, a person who worried about whether or not I wore my coat, fought with my dad about money, and liked buying shoes. I couldn't fathom her having in her past any of the experiences I was having.
Now I'm the mom of a high school sophomore. I'm on the other side. I watch her struggle with things. I ask her what's wrong; I glean details from facebook statuses and blog updates. Sometimes she tells me and other times not. Sometimes we are able to talk and sometimes we can't. I wonder: when did it grow so hard? When did she stop telling me? How can I be around her so that she can trust me? I think about what I know of her experiences by way of my own. I wish I could translate it for her. I wish she could know: I know.
Sure, the details have changed. Clothes, hair, music, watch styles. There are cell phones and texting and tweeting (all stuff that, honestly? I'm glad I didn't have in high school because they make you that much more vulnerable to ridicule). The texture of her life is different than mine was. But the landscape is the same: she still has to traverse boys and friends and homework and temptations and figuring out who she is, what she believes, who she wants to become. I didn't manage my adolescent journey well, but that isn't necessarily a weakness; I know where the dead ends and the steep falls are.
The landscape is the same. But so is the resistance to the mother. I remember that, too, the way your mother seems when you are a teenager: soft, aging, unconnected. Starting to wrinkle, to sag at the arm and at the belly. Concerned with stuff that doesn't really matter to who you are; prone to get annoyed at the completely inconsequential thing; a barrier you have to cross to get where you want to go. Mothers didn't get it. They wanted you to stay home from the party. They said stuff like "nothing good ever happens after 11:00" and "you call that dancing?" They embarrassed you by insisting you wear your coat. The only thing they had in common with you was living in the same house.
They'd never experienced what you were experiencing.
At least, that was how my mother seemed to me. Did she have to choose whether or not she'd party because her friends did? I couldn't imagine. Did she stand in front of the mirror and wish everything about her was different? My mother seemed secure in her skin, not questioning. Did she ever feel that horribly amazing constriction that flashed from your throat to your fingertips to the roots of your hair to your toenails to your teeth when she saw The Boy? Who wants to think of their mother feeling that? Disgusting! I couldn't imagine her ever feeling what I was. Even though she probably did.
Perhaps, though, her relating is inconsequential. Maybe the fact that the landscape is the same doesn't matter. Maybe seeing your mom through the lens of annoyance and frustration is a key part of growing up; maybe it allows the daughter to let go of the connected closeness of childhood so that she can become her own person instead of a younger version of her mother. Maybe she simply needs to find her own way.
So I watch. I try to offer what I can, when it is acceptable. I try to not be annoying and to only press for the important things. (If she doesn't want to wear her coat, she can choose to be cold.) I look for openings. I also see. I see when she is hurting over something, and I wish. I wish she could know I have gone down that same path. My knees have bled too, from stumbling. I wish my knowledge, scarred as it is, could be the thing that pulls her up and steadies her. But she pushes back; she pushes away. She walks alone, as maybe we all must. She has to make the journey, and when she will not allow me to walk beside her, I try to let her see me on the side of the road, encouraging her.
And I hope. I hope so hard that somewhere further down the trail lies a landscape we can truly walk together through. I have seen it in dreams. I hope we make it there.